© BarbarescoNevertheless, some wineries seem to have harvested their grapes too early rather than too late and were not too serious about selection. Some wines lack density, complexity and fruit charm despite noticeable alcoholic strength; the tannins often turn out relatively brittle and drying and the ethereal aromas so typical of Nebbiolo sometimes turn camphor-like green. While the best wines gain depth in the air and become smoother and finer, the less good examples hardly develop positively or even in the opposite direction after opening - they become more brittle and even greener.
At the top of the vintage, as far as we have tasted it so far, are some exceptionally fine and complex wines. They are Barbaresco as we would like them to be, with elegance, depth and, for all their power, charm. Many of them are so solidly built that they should be allowed to mature for a few more years, while others are already so beguiling and accessible that it would do no harm to drink them, if not this autumn, then at least next autumn - without having to hurry, of course. For while one can assume that the brittle and sometimes a little green wines will not be much more enjoyable to drink in the future than they are today, those that present themselves harmoniously even when young generally mature best.
We have tasted 90 Barbaresco in the past weeks, 70 of them from the 2019 vintage. All relevant producers were invited, but not all of them submitted wines, which is why some well-known top producers are missing from our list so far. Since, for good reasons, we never taste at fairs, presentations or on site at the producer's, we cannot fill the gaps like this. However, we will send out another invitation this year. We will submit samples later or present them in the next "In Focus: Barbaresco" in autumn 2023.
All wines were tasted blind several times in our tasting room in Erlangen. We present the best results here. Links to all ratings with detailed descriptions as well as the producers can be found at the end of each of the best lists.
Castello di Neive
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Albesani "Santo Stefano®"
50.00 €
Tenute Cisa Asinari dei Marchesi di Gresy
— Piedmont
2018 Barbaresco DOCG "Martinenga®"
Up to 60.00 €
CARLO GIACOSA
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG "Asili"
80.00 €
Paitin
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Faset
Castello di Neive
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Gallina
45.00 €
Az. Vitivinicola Boffa Carlo
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Ovello
Up to 55.00 €
Azienda Agricola Bera di Bera Valter
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Serraboella
34.00 €
Collina Serragrilli
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Starderi
50.00 €
Cortese Giuseppe Azienda Agricola
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Rabajà
Up to 55.00 €
Azienda Agricola Lodali Walter
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Giacone "Lorens"
42.00 €
GAJA
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG
91 WP
excellent
CARLO GIACOSA
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG "Montefico"
60.00 €
CARLO GIACOSA
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG "Ovello"
45.00 €
Angelo Negro
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Basarin
90 WP
excellent
33.00 €
Cortese Giuseppe Azienda Agricola
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG
Up to 35.00 €
Castello di Neive
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG
35.00 €
Salvano srl
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG
32.00 €
Paitin
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Serraboella
40.00 €
Giuseppe Negro
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG "Pian Cavallo"
35.00 €
Pio Cesare
— Piedmont
2018 Barbaresco DOCG "Pio"
60.00 €
Marchesi di Barolo
— Piedmont
2018 Barbaresco DOCG Serragrilli
40.00 €
Paitin
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Basarin
45.00 €
Az. Agr. Pelissero Pasquale di Pelissero Ornella
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG San Giuliano "Bricco"
Pertinace
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Marcarini
89 WP
very good
Pelissero
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG "Tulin®"
60.00 €
Walter Musso
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Pora
Up to 50.00 €
Mura Mura
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Faset
65.00 €
Mura Mura
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Serragrilli
70.00 €
Walter Musso
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Rio Sordo
Up to 50.00 €
Mura Mura
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Starderi
70.00 €
Ottavio Lequio - Prinsi
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Gallina
Up to 42.00 €
Demarie
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG
35.00 €
Collina Serragrilli
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Serragrilli
35.00 €
Azienda Agricola Rivetti Dante
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Bric Micca
28.00 €
Az. Agr. Fontanabianca
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG
Up to 30.00 €
Poderi Luigi Einaudi
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG
89 WP
very good
40.00 €
Viglione Achille Sas
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG "Jacco"
35.00 €
Antica Casa Vinicola Scarpa
— Piedmont
2018 Barbaresco DOCG "Tettineive®"
89 WP
very good
56.00 €
Batasiolo spa
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG
27.00 €
Azienda Agricola Bera di Bera Valter
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG
26.00 €
Paitin
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Serraboella "Sori' Paitin"
50.00 €
Az. Vitivinicola Boffa Carlo
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG
30.00 €
Paolo Manzone
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG San Giuliano
Up to 50.00 €
Adriano Marco e Vittorio
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Basarin
Up to 40.00 €
Az. Agr. Fontanabianca
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG Bordini
Up to 40.00 €
CARLO GIACOSA
— Piedmont
2019 Barbaresco DOCG
35.00 €
Tenute Cisa Asinari dei Marchesi di Gresy
— Piedmont
2018 Barbaresco DOCG "Martinenga®"
Up to 60.00 €
Pio Cesare
— Piedmont
2018 Barbaresco DOCG "Pio"
60.00 €
Marchesi di Barolo
— Piedmont
2018 Barbaresco DOCG Serragrilli
40.00 €
Antica Casa Vinicola Scarpa
— Piedmont
2018 Barbaresco DOCG "Tettineive®"
89 WP
very good
56.00 €
Castello di Neive
— Piedmont
2017 Barbaresco DOCG Albesani Riserva "Santo Stefano®"
60.00 €
Socré
— Piedmont
2017 Barbaresco DOCG Roncaglie Riserva
Up to 80.00 €
Rossello Vini
— Piedmont
2017 Barbaresco DOCG
26.50 €
Rivella Serafino
— Piedmont
2013 Barbaresco DOCG Montestefano
Up to 100.00 €
Demarie
— Piedmont
2008 Barbaresco DOCG Riserva
60.00 €
Tenute Cisa Asinari dei Marchesi di Gresy
— Piedmont
2004 Barbaresco DOCG Gaiun Martinenga
Up to 50.00 €
Ottavio Lequio - Prinsi
— Piedmont
2016 Barbaresco DOCG Riserva "Fausoni"
Up to 48.00 €
Azienda Agricola Bera di Bera Valter
— Piedmont
2013 Barbaresco DOCG Basarin Riserva
46.00 €
Punset di Marcarino Marina & C. sas
— Piedmont
2015 Barbaresco DOCG San Cristoforo Campo Quadro Riserva
Adriano Marco e Vittorio
— Piedmont
2016 Barbaresco DOCG Basarin Riserva
Up to 50.00 €
Azienda Agricola Bera di Bera Valter
— Piedmont
2015 Barbaresco DOCG Rabajà Riserva
50.00 €
Castello di Neive
— Piedmont
2014 Barbaresco DOCG
Up to 25.00 €