© Karl Haidle WineryMoreover, it is an ideal complement to Pinot Noir: it is dark in colour, has more tannin and - even if we do not want to idealise it at all - is much better suited to a style of wine-making that likes to call itself "international": powerful and with a rather hearty use of wood. Pinot Noir rarely tolerates this, and even if the result is an objectively good wine, there is usually little left of the varietal character in this treatment. With Lemberger it is quite different, at least as long as one does not completely overdo it.
But at the other end of the scale, among the entry-level wines, Lemberger occupies a place where Pinot Noir is hardly ever convincing. For even well under 10 euros, amazing wines can sometimes be found that are not only carefully made and palatable, but also bring animated freshness, juiciness and even a certain character.
Our favourite wines among the Lembergers are then also those that retain this freshness, coolness and precision even in higher weight classes. Where concentration meets delicacy, juiciness meets elegance and real depth of fruit, we always feel most comfortable with the variety.
Good, but that's basically how we feel about all wines....
Over the past few weeks, we have tasted around 70 Lemberger or Blaufränkisch from Germany, of which we present the best here. Unfortunately, not all of the wineries we asked for accepted our invitation, including some of the younger ones that have caught our eye in the recent past. Should further samples arrive in the foreseeable future, we will submit their results immediately. Links to all the wines tasted can be found under the respective best lists.
Weingut Aldinger
— Württemberg
2020 Fellbach Lämmler Lemberger Grosses Gewächs
92 WP
excellent
42.00 €
Weingut Karl Haidle
— Württemberg
2020 Stetten Gernhalde Lemberger Grosses Gewächs trocken
92 WP
excellent
48.00 €
Weingut Karl Haidle
— Württemberg
2020 Stetten Berge Lemberger Grosses Gewächs trocken
91 WP
excellent
38.00 €
Weingut Eisele
— Neckar
2020 Lemberger Landwein trocken "Muschelkalk" Goldkapsel
25.00 €
Weingut Eisele
— Neckar
2020 Lemberger Landwein trocken "Gipskeuper" Goldkapsel
25.00 €
Weingut Seeger
— Baden
2020 Leimen Herrenberg Blaufränkisch Grosses Gewächs trocken "Spermen R"
90 WP
excellent
29.00 €
Weingut Graf Neipperg
— Württemberg
2020 Neipperg Schlossberg Lemberger Grosses Gewächs trocken
30.00 €
Weingut Heid
— Württemberg
2020 Fellbach Lämmler Lemberger Grosses Gewächs trocken
90 WP
excellent
30.00 €
St. Antony
— Rheinhessen
2020 Blaufränkisch trocken "Rothe Bach"
89 WP
very good
42.00 €
Weingut Wöhrwag
— Württemberg
2020 Untertürkheim Herzogenberg Lemberger Grosses Gewächs trocken
89 WP
very good
27.50 €
Bürgerspital zum Hl. Geist - Weingut
— Franconia/Franken
2020 Würzburg Stein Blaufränkisch VDP.Erste Lage trocken "R"
88 WP
very good
23.00 €
Weingut Eisele
— Neckar
2020 Lemberger Landwein trocken "Muschelkalk" Silberkapsel
16.00 €
Weingut Rainer Schnaitmann
— Württemberg
2020 Fellbach Lämmler Lemberger Grosses Gewächs trocken
88 WP
very good
58.00 €
Weingut Jürgen Ellwanger
— Württemberg
2020 Hebsacker Berg Lemberger Grosses Gewächs trocken
88 WP
very good
32.00 €
Weingut Heid
— Württemberg
2020 Fellbach Goldberg Lemberger VDP.Erste Lage trocken
88 WP
very good
15.00 €
Weingut Fürst Hohenlohe-Oehringen
— Württemberg
2020 Verrenberg Verrenberg Lemberger Grosses Gewächs trocken
87 WP
very good
Weingut Dautel
— Württemberg
2019 Cleebronn Michaelsberg Lemberger Grosses Gewächs trocken
90 WP
excellent
Weingut Klumpp
— Baden
2019 Zeutern Himmelreich Blaufränkisch trocken
89 WP
very good
25.00 €
Weingut Zimmerle
— Württemberg
2019 Korb Berg Lemberger trocken "Goldadler"
89 WP
very good
33.00 €
Weingut Heid
— Württemberg
2019 Schorndorf Grafenberg Lemberger VDP.Erste Lage trocken
88 WP
very good
18.00 €
Weingut Rainer Schnaitmann
— Schwaben
2019 Lemberger Landwein trocken "Simonroth®"
88 WP
very good
24.00 €
Weingut G.A. Heinrich
— Württemberg
2019 Heilbronn Stiftsberg Lemberger trocken "G.A."
88 WP
very good
16.00 €
Weingut Albrecht Schwegler
— Württemberg
2019 Lemberger Reserve
88 WP
very good
38.00 €
Weingut Graf von Bentzel-Sturmfeder
— Württemberg
2019 Schozach Lemberger VDP.Ortswein trocken ***
87 WP
very good
13.90 €
Weingut Jürgen Ellwanger
— Württemberg
2018 Lemberger trocken "Hades"
90 WP
excellent
26.00 €
Weingut Dautel
— Württemberg
2018 Cleebronn Michaelsberg Lemberger Grosses Gewächs trocken
89 WP
very good
34.00 €
Fellbacher Weingärtner eG
— Württemberg
2018 Fellbach Lämmler Lemberger trocken "Edition P"
87 WP
very good
19.50 €
Fellbacher Weingärtner eG
— Württemberg
2018 Fellbach Lämmler Lemberger Grosses Gewächs trocken
88 WP
very good
26.90 €
Weingut Graf von Bentzel-Sturmfeder
— Württemberg
2018 Schozach Lemberger VDP.Ortswein trocken ***
88 WP
very good
13.90 €
Weingut Stefan Bardorf
— Franconia/Franken
2018 Randersacker Sonnenstuhl Blaufränkisch trocken
88 WP
very good
14.00 €
Weingut Heußler und Töchter GbR
— Pfalz
2018 Rhodt Klosterpfad Lemberger trocken "Linie B"
87 WP
very good
15.00 €
Weingut G.A. Heinrich
— Württemberg
2015 Heilbronn Vorderer Hundsberg Lemberger trocken
87 WP
very good
40.00 €
Weingut Burg Ravensburg
— Baden
2017 Sulzfeld Lerchenberg Blaufränkisch VDP.Erste Lage trocken
87 WP
very good
18.00 €
Weingut Burg Ravensburg
— Baden
2011 Blaufränkisch VDP.Grosse Lage trocken "Dicker Franz"
87 WP
very good
43.00 €
Weingut Stefan Bardorf
— Franconia/Franken
2016 Randersacker Sonnenstuhl Blaufränkisch trocken
87 WP
very good
12.50 €
Weingut Heußler und Töchter GbR
— Pfalz
2020 Rhodt Klosterpfad Lemberger trocken
86 WP
very good
7.00 €
Weingut Graf von Bentzel-Sturmfeder
— Württemberg
2019 Blaufränkisch VDP.Gutswein trocken **
86 WP
very good
8.90 €
Weingut Medinger
— Württemberg
2019 Lemberger trocken
86 WP
very good
7.50 €
Weingut Medinger
— Württemberg
2018 Lemberger trocken "Bürger Wein"
86 WP
very good
8.50 €
Weingut Graf von Bentzel-Sturmfeder
— Württemberg
2018 Lemberger VDP.Gutswein trocken "Sturmfeder"
86 WP
very good
6.90 €
Weingut Siegloch
— Neckar
2020 Lemberger Landwein trocken
85 WP
very good
7.80 €
Weingut Reinhard Schäfer
— Württemberg
2019 Lemberger trocken "S"
85 WP
very good
8.80 €